ISSN 1117-0530

KINGS LAW REPORTS

(ALL SC)

COMPREHENSIVE INDEX TO

ALL SUPREME COURT 1997 DECISIONS

REPORTED IN (1997) VOLS. 1 - 12 KLR (PTS. 47-55)

[TOTALLING 99 JUDGMENTS IN ALL]

Dedicated to the King of kings

O. O. NOEL ESQ. Chief Editor


JUSTICES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

THE Hon. Justice Muhammadu Lawal Uwais - Chief Justice of Nigeria

THE Hon. Justice ADOLPHUS GODWIN Karibi-Whyte

THE Hon. Justice SALIHU MODIBBO ALFA Belgore

THE Hon. Justice ABUBAKAR BASHIR Wali

THE Hon. Justice IDRIS LEGBO Kutigi

THE Hon. Justice MICHAEL EKUNDAYO Ogundare

THE Hon. Justice EMMANUEL OBIOMA Ogwuegbu

THE Hon. Justice UTHMAN Mohammed

THE Hon. Justice SYLVESTER UMARU Onu

*THE Hon. Justice YEKINI OLAYIWOLA ADIO (DECEASED)

THE Hon. Justice ANTHONY IKECHUKWU Iguh

LIST OF ALL SC 1997 DECISIONS REPORTED

ADESOKAN V. ADEGOROLU (1997) 3 KLR (PT 49) 505

ADEYERI V. OKOBI (1997) 6 KLR (PT 52) 1188

AGBAISI V. EBIKOREFE (1997) 4 KLR (PT 51) 767

AKINNUBI V. AKINNUBI (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 257

ALLIED BANK V. AKUBUEZE (1997) 6 KLR (PT 52) 1202

ALOR V. THE STATE (1997) 4 KLR (PT 51) 790

AMUDA V. ADELODUN (1997) 5 KLR (PT 52) 1071

ANABARONYE V. NWAKAIHE (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 190

ATOLAGBE V. AWUNI (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1348

BOLEX ENT. LTD V. INCAR NIG. PLC (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1563

BOMOR V. EKIYOR (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1571


LIST OF ALL SC 1997 DECISIONS REPORTED

BRAIDE V. THE STATE (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 1059

CHIEKE V. OLUSOGA (1997) 3 KLR (PT 49) 547

CITY ENGINEERING LTD V. F.H.A (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1874

CLAY INDUSTRIES LTD V. AINA (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1603

COKER V. UBA PLC (1997) 2 KLR (PT 48) 413

COMEX LTD V. NIGERIA ARAB BANK LTD (1997) 4 KLR (PT 50) 653

DAKAT V. DASHE (1997) 12 KLR (PT 55) 2053

EBOADE V. ATOMESIN (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 849

EBOHON V. A-G EDO STATE (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 1023

EDEBIRI V. EDEBIRI (1997) 4 KLR (PT 50) 672

EDOKPOLOR & CO. LTD V. BENDEL INSUR. CO. LTD (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 214

EGBARAN V. AKPOTOR (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1856

EGBO V. AGBARA (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 1

EGBUONU V. BORNU RADIO TV. CORP (1997) 12 KLR (PT 55) 2063

EJINDU V. OBI (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 113

EKENNIA V. NKPAKARA (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 869

ENOGA V. THE STATE (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54

FADLALLAH V. AREWA TEXTILES LTD (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1527

FASESIN V. OYERINDE (1997) 12 KLR (PT 55) 1987

GARBA V. THE STATE (1997) 3 KLR (PT 49) 529

GOV. ANAMBRA STATE V. EZEMUOKWE (1997) 3 KLR (PT 49) 561

GOVERNOR IMO STATE V. NWAUWA (1997) 2 KLR (PT 48) 327

HAAV V. KUNDU (1997) 5 KLR (PT 52) 1079

HOUTMANGRACHT V. ODUBA (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 1037

IBEH V. THE STATE (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 134

IBIDAPO V. LUFTHANSA AIRLINES (1997) 4 KLR (PT 50) 734

IDEHEN V. OSEMWENKHAE (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1584

IDESOH V. ORDIA (1997) 2 KLR (PT 48) 459

IHENACHO V. UZOCHUKWU (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 241

IKEANYI V. ACB LTD (1997) 2 KLR (PT 48) 373

IKENNA V. BOSAH (1997) 3 KLR (PT 49) 589

ILEDARE V. AJAGBONNA (1997) 5 KLR (PT 52) 1122

ILODIBIA V. NIGERIAN CEMENT COMPANY LTD (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1318

ISERU V. CATHOLIC BISHOP OF WARRI DIOCESE (1997) 4 KLR (PT 50) 618

ISHOLA V. SOCIETE GENERAIE BANK (1997) 2 KLR (PT 48) 293

IWUOHA V. NIGERIA RAILWAY CORPORATION (1997) 4 KLR (PT 50) 601

J.A.S. & CO. LTD V. NAT. CEREALS RES. INST. (1997) 2 KLR (PT 48) 441

J.E. OSHEVIRE LTD V. TRIPOLI MOTORS (1997) 4 KLR (PT 51) 823

KAMALU V. UMUNNA (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 1001


LIST OF ALL SC 1997 DECISIONS REPORTED

KARI V. GANARAM (1997) 2 KLR (PT 48) 391

KOYA V. UBA LTD (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 73

LADEPO V. AJANI (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1709

LAWSON V. AJIBULU (1997) 6 KLR (PT 52) 1135

LEKWOT V. JUDICIAL TRIBUNAL (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1904

MADU V. THE STATE (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 26

MOHAMMED V. THE STATE (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1766

MUSA V. YERIMA (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1295

NATIONAL HORT. RESEARCH INST. V. AYOADE (1997) 12 KLR (PT 55) 1976

NDIC V. FMB LTD (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 924

NEPA V. ONAH (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 201

NKADO V. OBIANO (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 891

NWOSU V. OFFOR (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 272

NYAMBI V. OSADIM (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 281

OBRI V. THE STATE (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1440

ODEBUNMI V. ABDULLAHI (1997) 2 KLR (PT 48) 357

ODEKILEKUN V. HASSAN (1997) 12 KLR (PT 55) 2026

ODU'A INVESTMENT CO. LTD V. TALABI (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1628

ODUSOGA V. RICKETTS (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53)

OGIGIE V. OBIYAN (1997) 10 KLR (PT 55) 1915

OGUALAJI V. A-G RIVERS STATE (1997) 5 KLR (PT 52) 1085

OGUALAJI V. A-G RIVERS STATE (1997) 5 KLR (PT 52) 1085

OGUNDARE V. OGUNLOWO (1997) 5 KLR (PT 52) 1110

OKONKWO V. UDOH (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1722

OLANREWAJU V. OGUNLEYE (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 225

OLAOPA V. OBAFEMI AWOLOWO UNIVERSITY (1997) 6 KLR (PT 52) 1167

ONAMADE V. ACB LTD (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 48

OSEYOMON V. OJO (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54)

OTUEDON V. OLUGHOR (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1731

OVIAWE V. INTEGRATED RUBBER PRODUCTS LTD (1997) 3 KLR (PT 49) 469

OWENA BANK V. NIGERIAN STOCK EXCH. LTD (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1421

OYENIRAN V. EGBETOLA (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51

PAN ATLANTIC LTD V. RHEIN MASS GMBH (1997) 3 KLR (PT 49) 577

PASCUTTO V. ADECENTRO NIG. LTD (1997) 12 KLR (PT 55) 1932

PETER V. THE STATE (1997) 3 KLR (PT 49) 487

PETER V. THE STATE (1997) 12 KLR (PT 55) 1999

SALAKO V. DOSUNMU (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1476

SALAMI V. GBODOOLU (1997) 4 KLR (PT 50) 689

SANUSI V. ADEBIYI (1997) 12 KLR (PT 55) 1959

SOCIETE GENERALE FRANCE V. SOCIETE GENERALE BANK (NIG) LTD


LIST OF ALL SC 1997 DECISIONS REPORTED

(1997) 4 KLR (PT 50) 631

THE VESSEL "ST ROLAND" V. OSINLOYE (1997) 4 KLR (PT 51) 797

THE STATE V. DANJUMA (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51)

TUKUR V. GOVERNMENT OF TARABA STATE (1997) 6 KLR (PT 52) 1238

UDOM V. MICHELETTI & SONS LTD (1997) 7 KLR (PT 54) 1690

UGU V. TABI (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1547

UKATTA V. NDINAEZE (1997) 4 KLR (PT 50) 708

UKWU V. BUNGE (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1512

UMUKORO V. NPA (1997) 5 KLR (PT 51) 954

USMAN V. KUSFA (1997) 1 KLR (PT 47) 179

UZOCHUKWU V. ERI (1997) 7 KLR (PT 53) 1453

SUBJECT MATTER CONTENTS

ACCIDENTS ......................................................... 2077

ACTIONS .................................................................................... 2077

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW ......................................... 2082

ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE ................... 2082

AFFIDAVITS .................................................................... 2082

AGENCY ............................................................. 2082

AGREEMENTS .............................. 2083

APPEALS ..................................................... 2083

ARBITRATION ........................................................... 2093

AUCTIONEERS LAW ................................. 2094

BANKING .................................................................. 2094

CARRIAGE OF GOODS ................................ 2095

CHIEFTAINCY MATTERS ...................................... 2096

CLAIMS ..................................................... 2097

COMPANY LAW ............................................... 2099

CONFLICT OF LAWS ................................ 2100

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW .......................................... 2100


SUBJECT MATTER CONTENTS

CONTRACTS ........................................... 2101

CONVEYANCING ................................................... 2105

CORROBORATION ................................ 2106

COURT PROCESSES ........................................... 2106

COURTS ............................................. 2107

CRIMINAL LAW ............................................. 2113

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE .................... 2114

CROSS EXAMINATION ....................................... 2117

CULPABLE HOMICIDE ..................................................... 2118

CUSTOMARY LAW .................................... 2118

DAMAGES ................................................................. 2118

DECLARATIONS ............................................. 2120

DOCUMENTS ...................................... 2120

EQUITY .................................................................................... 2122

ESTOPPEL .............................................................. 2123

EVIDENCE ............................................ 2123

FAIR HEARING ................................................. 2135

INJUNCTIONS ...................................... 2136

INSURANCE ......................................................... 2136

INTERNATIONAL LAW .................................................... 2136

INTERPRETATION OF STATUTES ..................................................... 2137

ISLAMIC LAW ....................................... 2137

JUDGMENTS .............................................................. 2137

JUDICIAL PRECEDENTS ................................. 2143

JURISDICTION ............................................................................ 2144

LAND LAW .................................................. 2145

LAND USE ACT ....................................................... 2156

LANDLORD & TENANT ....................................................... 2157

LEASES .................................................... 2157

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS ..................................... 2158

LEGISLATION ................................ 2158

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS ........................... 2158

LOCUS IN QUO ...................................... 2160

LOCUS STANDI ............................................................................... 2160

MASTER & SERVANT ........................................ 2160

MATRIMONIAL CAUSES ...................................................... 2160

MORTGAGES ....................................... 2160

MOTION ON NOTICE .......................................... 2161

MURDER ................................... 2161


SUBJECT MATTER CONTENTS

NATURAL JUSTICE .................................................. 2161

NEGLIGENCE .............................................. 2161

OBJECTIONS .................................. 2162

ORDERS ........................................................... 2162

PARTIES ............................................. 2163

PLEADINGS ....................................................... 2163

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE ............................................. 2167

RES JUDICATA ............................... 2170

RULES OF COURT ........................................ 2171

SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE ................................. 2172

STATUTES ..................................... 2172

SUCCESSION ............................................... 2174

SUPREME COURT ....................................................... 2174

TORTS ............................................. 2175

TRESPASS ............................................................. 2176

WAIVER .................................. 2177

WORDS & PHRASES ................................ 2178

WRIT OF SUMMONS .......................................................... 2178